What's your guess, how many stories posted as "real" are actually true?

[Andrew Kanagal]

So we have this fetish and like stories where the woman wins. And it definitely happens, it is possible, that's not my point. Women can beat men with superior technique and some women are stronger than some men.

At the same time anybody who has some real martial arts experience or just is realistic about this topic knows that it's pretty rare in reality that women are stronger than men, beat them up, destroy them etc. It's just very seldom.

There is a reason that competitions in almost every sport have different classes for men and women. There is a reason that you don't see women taking on men in the Octagon.
And even to beat up the often mentioned "average male" a woman has to be either a really good fighter or strength wise among the top 10% of women, because that's about how strong an average male is.

Yet if you look at a forum like here you have stories where women beat the crap out of males all the time, so many of them are described as real. Almost everybody who has this fetish seems to also experience something which fulfills it.

I've never ever had a physical confrontation with a woman in my entire life outside the gym and I don't know a single friend who had one. And in the gym I grappled with probably hundred different women over all the years of training but I never got dominated and I'm definitely not a beast for a man.

So what's your take on that? You think almost all of them are fake? Some true, some fake? 50:50? How often does it actually happen? How many stories do you believe?

[wgonzo64]

I would say 75/25 but as long as they are well written I read and enjoy.

[Andrew Kanagal]

Originally Posted by wgonzo64 [Only Registered Users Can See LinksClick Here To Register]

I would say 75/25 but as long as they are well written I read and enjoy.

You mean 75-fake 25-true right?

[wgonzo64]

Originally Posted by Andrew Kanagal [Only Registered Users Can See LinksClick Here To Register]

You mean 75-fake 25-true right?

yes but that's my opinion I have no proof

[Braddogg4345]

My guess is that most are fake

[trump55]

At least 90% fake or real stories with many fake parts and details.

[djpapajoe]

My guess is most are fake. But if they are good stories, who cares. The stories are here for our enjoyment, so lets enjoy them.

[Andrew Kanagal]

Originally Posted by djpapajoe [Only Registered Users Can See LinksClick Here To Register]

My guess is most are fake. But if they are good stories, who cares. The stories are here for our enjoyment, so lets enjoy them.

Sure but personally I'd prefer to post fantasy stories as fake stories.
At least the ones which obviously didn't happen like that.
If everybody posts stories where a girl beats five guys into hospital by applying typical wrestling moves and scissoring them, it sort of takes away the appeal of actual true stories.

For me those are two categories. I can enjoy fake stories which are over the top, no problem.
But more realistic, real stories also have their own appeal. If a story is real it doesn't have to be as 'dominant' a good scuffle with a girl is enough that I find it interesting.
But since everybody posts everything as real and 90% of the users mention in some thread how they were beat up by a 6'0 amazon etc it doesn't have any value anymore if somebody says he tells a 'true' story.

[stymie]

Are you talking about the Wrestling & Fighting Stories section? I figure they're all fantasy or at least greatly embellished, which isn't my interest

[wrestl2424]

I remember posting a story that actually happened in the old yahoo true story group back in the day. Basically, I was laying on the floor on my side looking at a photo album at my ex girlfriend's grandmother's house when my ex took the opportunity to put me in a front headscissor. She knew of my fetish as I taught her the move but she did it on this occasion just to embarrass me in front of her family I guess. Her grandma laughed and commented that she was really mean because the tightness of the scissor caused me to clearly moan in pain (she was an equestrian, rock hard legs when flexed/scissoring) and tapping for her to stop. I remember the moderator critiquing my story that it would have been better if my ex verbally humiliated me or I should have added additional similar details. Like WTF, its a true story group I told one just as it happened. Remember thinking how lame it was to encourage people to embellish on their 'true' stories.